The Genealogical Helper: query 13-4-85 on Elizabeth Ann Whatley and Edmund Griffith Carlisle
December 1959 · The Genealogical Helper, vol. 13, no. 4 (Logan, Utah: Everton Publishers, December 1959)
Named here: Elizabeth Ann Whatley, Edmund Carlile
The book at the Internet Archive
Transcription
From the archive.org text layer (the querist's name and address omitted here):
13-4-85 Moore, Whatley, Carlisle, Evans, Murray (McMurray)
[Querist], […] desires info on these anc: […] 2 Elizabeth Ann Whatley, b 1770 near Princeton, NJ, d 1856 Miltown, Ala m 1795? Edmund Griffith Carlisle a RW sol, b 1750 NC, d Morgan co, Ga, will probated 1828. Would like their p and ch. […]
Citation: Query 13-4-85, "Moore, Whatley, Carlisle, Evans, Murray (McMurray)," The Genealogical Helper 13, no. 4 (December 1959): 219; Internet Archive item sim_evertons-genealogical-helper_1959-12_13_4, https://archive.org/details/sim_evertons-genealogical-helper_1959-12_13_4?q=%22Elizabeth+Ann+Whatley%22.
What it says, against the tree
Each fact this record gives, set beside what the FamilySearch tree says: it agrees, it is new (the tree lacks it), it conflicts, or it is context.
| Person | Fact | Document says | Tree says | Assessment |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Elizabeth Ann Whatley | Birth | 1770, near Princeton, New Jersey | 27 January 1779, Wilkes, Georgia | conflicts |
| Elizabeth Ann Whatley | Death | 1856, Milltown, Alabama | 15 November 1854, Milltown, Chambers, Alabama | agrees (place); conflicts (year) |
| Elizabeth Ann Whatley, Edmund Carlile | Marriage | About 1795 (queried) | 1796, Jackson, Georgia | agrees roughly |
| Edmund Carlile | Name | Edmund Griffith Carlisle | Edmund Carlile | new (middle name) |
| Edmund Carlile | Birth | 1750, North Carolina | 1776, Edgecombe, North Carolina | conflicts (year) |
| Edmund Carlile | Death | Morgan County, Ga.; will probated 1828 | 13 April 1828, Morgan, Georgia | agrees |
| Edmund Carlile | Service | "a RW sol" (Revolutionary War soldier) | — | new, doubtful (see notes) |